Issue Information

HEALTH CARE

Mandate To Cover Mental Health Conditions Still In Play

The Senate is expected to consider SB 5 (Hottinger, R-Newark), a health care bill that makes minor changes to Ohio’s Small Employer Health Care Alliance law, when it returns for a lame duck session after the November election. The Ohio Chamber is very concerned the bill could be amended on the Senate floor to include a controversial mental health parity amendment. This mandate would require employers to pay for health insurance coverage for mental illnesses under their group health care policies just like they cover physical conditions. The “mental health parity” mandate could undermine the efforts of many Ohio employers to control their health care costs.

The Ohio Chamber has a long-standing policy against all health care mandates. There are several reasons why the Chamber takes this position. The first is the direct cost impact mandates have on small businesses. Unlike self-insured companies who are exempt from state regulation, small businesses absorb the full cost of each new state mandate. These are often the same businesses that are struggling to pay for health care coverage for their employees as they face premium increases exceeding 30% per year. Ohio already has 32 separate health insurance coverage or process mandates. Adding mental health parity to this list will force more small employers to curtail health care benefits and result in fewer Ohioans having any health insurance at all.

A second reason for the Chamber’s opposition to health care mandates is our commitment to the free market. Businesses should be able to decide what diseases, medical conditions and other benefits they include in their health insurance coverage. They know best what they can afford and should have a broad range of options to “tailor” a health insurance plan to the characteristics of their workforce. Why should businesses be forced to pay for a benefit that is not likely to be utilized by their employees or pay the cost of covering a condition(s) that prices them out of the insurance market?

For these reasons, the Ohio Chamber opposes all health care mandates and makes no attempt to distinguish or compare medical conditions for the purpose of deciding what should or should not be a basic benefit. Our state and federal lawmakers need to do everything they can to reduce the cost of health care. With the number of uninsured climbing, piling on more government-imposed health care mandates is the wrong answer at the wrong time.

To learn more about this issue, please contact Steve Warden, Director, Ohio Small Business Council.