Legislative Victories


Economic Impact Analysis - Summary

On Dec. 16, 1999, Gov. Bob Taft signed HB 13, sponsored by Rep. Don Mottley (R-W. Carrollton). The new Act became effective immediately and creates two one-year pilot programs designed to identify the financial impact of pending laws, resolutions and rules on Ohio businesses.

The first pilot program focuses on proposed bills and resolutions.

  • This one-year pilot program is limited to legislation assigned to three House and three Senate committees. The participating Senate Committees include: Health, Human Services & Aging; Insurance, Commerce & Labor; Ways & Means. The designated House Committees are: Commerce & Labor; Insurance; Ways & Means.
  • During the one-year pilot period, the chair of each selected committee, in consultation with the ranking minority member, may request that the Legislative Budget Office (LBO) analyze a maximum of three bills or resolutions believed to have a significant cost impact on Ohio businesses.
  • When directed to perform such an analysis, the LBO must determine if there is a likelihood the proposed bill or resolution could have a significant economic impact on Ohio businesses. If LBO finds a significant economic impact could exist, it must include information in the fiscal analysis of the bill or resolution indicating whether the bill or resolution could significantly:
    • increase or decrease the revenues or expenditures of Ohio businesses in general;
    • impact Ohio small businesses in particular, including their access to a workforce; and
    • impact particular segments of Ohio industry, including any variable geographical impact felt by businesses located in counties bordering neighboring states.
The second pilot program is directed toward the rule-making process.

  • During 2000, the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (OEPA) and the Department of Development (DOD) must analyze certain proposed rules to determine their economic impact on Ohio businesses. In analyzing a proposed rule, the agency must:
    • Make a good faith effort to identify Ohio businesses that may be significantly affected by the rule and engage leading individuals from those businesses in the review process;
    • Analyze and incorporate the comments received from such individuals along with the agency's expertise and experience in the economic impact of the rule; and
    • To the extent practicable, include information in the analysis indicating whether the rule could significantly:
      • increase or decrease the cost of regulatory compliance for Ohio businesses;
      • increase or decrease the overall regulatory burden on Ohio businesses;
      • affect the time involved in the agency's issuance of licenses, permits, or other forms of authorization; and
      • any other information the agency considers necessary to fully explain the economic impact of the proposed rule on Ohio businesses
Final Reports.
At the conclusion of the pilot program, the LBO, participating agencies and the Joint Committee on Agency Rule Review (JCARR) must submit separate reports to the governor and legislative leaders. Reports must be submitted by February 1, 2001.

Each report must state whether the pilot program should be continued and recommend whether the program: (1) should be continued as a pilot program for a specified period of time or be made permanent; (2) should be expanded to include other rule-making agencies; (3) requires different or additional exemptions; and (4) requires changes to improve its operating efficiency or to make it more likely that its objectives will be achieved.